A Deep Film Born from the Small Moments of Everyday Life
A review of the film There Are Mountains Among the Clouds, directed by Valdemar Bergman and Mio Mango

The feature film There Are Mountains Among the Clouds opens with an image of a tree. In an upward shot that shows part of the tree’s branches and leaves against the sky, a gentle breeze moves through the foliage, and the sound of birdsong can be heard. This scene, and the ones that follow—a view of the sky and a view of a woodland—are not merely a way of introducing the character’s living environment. These shots are meant to establish the directors’ approach to the question of narrative and the relationship between narrative and reality. Through these opening images we understand what the filmmakers believe about the role of an introduction in a film, and what kind of work we are dealing with. Every film constructs its own reality, and that construction of reality begins precisely with the first image, with the very first step. The path that Valdemar Bergman and Mio Mango take is, in fact, full of carefully considered details that must not be overlooked if one is to understand their work more fully.

After this unconventional prologue the film introduces its character, but in an aura of mystery. First, we see him sitting with his back to the camera. Second, what he says consists of enigmatic sentences about killing another person: that he does not understand the matter of murder yet at the same time has considered himself justified. As this monologue continues, we realize that what we are seeing may in fact be a reflection of the character’s inner thoughts. A moving shot from aboard a ship—which, because of the Swedish flag, also implicitly recalls the story’s geographical setting—is accompanied by the character’s deeply private words about not wanting to die, about the suffering he endures, and of course about illness. To whom are the words of this unnamed character addressed? Whom is he speaking to? Himself? The film’s veiled allusions to murder, to illness, to an event whose nature remains unknown to us, and also to the question of “remembering,” reveal the film’s most important narrative method: the film finds its primary form through the act of remembering things and places. The opening shot we saw—the tree against the sky—was not, in fact, an omniscient prologue, but part of the character’s process of recollection. The film’s world considers itself indebted to the character’s inner world, and what we see is a mental image of the character’s interior: of his memories, of his memory, of the past. One might even suppose that these images are not necessarily reality but a reflection of the character’s feelings. In other words, we are watching the feelings of a person who is telling us a story, and in the process we do not know which image is real and which is mental. This ambiguity is the most important narrative feature of these very opening scenes.
There Are Mountains Among the Clouds is, in the precise sense of the word, an experimental film that, by using a situation, its psychological aspects, and the application of attractive formal ideas, tries to step outside familiar cinematic spaces and build a world of its own. It therefore has a very difficult task. When we are dealing with a cinematic work as a pure reflection of reality, the filmmaker’s difficulty lies in how to reflect objective realities in the work, how to film them, and how to advance the story within those realities. But when we face an experimental work that is not necessarily meant to be an objective record of moments of real life, the director has the difficult job of constructing a world of his own—not merely shaping special spaces that simultaneously serve as a suitable ground for advancing the narrative. Valdemar Bergman and Mio Mango have shaped these spaces well. Their most important point of support has been characterization. They have succeeded in creating a character who is tangible and real, and at the same time full of mystery, a character one must try to understand by reading between the lines of his words. The role of the screenplay therefore becomes very prominent. The written monologues have successfully maintained the narrow border between reality and fantasy in the character’s world—the narrow border between ambiguity and clarity, the narrow border between madness and reason.

The screenplay is written with great precision, and in this rich text every scene is carefully designed so that it has a specific function in relation to the scenes before and after it. For example, the shot in which water runs in the sink, fills the entire frame, and then empties is not merely a shot; it has a metaphorical function within the film’s semantic world. Or the shot that follows it—showing the character in the confined space of his home—is meant, in continuation of the shot we have just seen, to construct the character’s inner and outer condition: to show us that we are dealing with a character whose interior is overflowing, yet who himself is trapped and confined among the walls.

The filmmakers succeed in creating an extraordinary balance between monologue scenes and silent scenes. Following a mysterious character through day and night, at home and in the street, is meant to be part of the process of the character’s psychology—a carefully considered and artistic psychology that has given the film’s visual aspects a considerable richness. There Are Mountains Among the Clouds is a delicate and profound attempt to approach a film-essay, a highly experimental film that tries to avoid the conventional language of the cinema of its time and designs its own world with precision and skill. A world in which images alone advance the narrative, and the narrative is not necessarily required to contain extensive dramatic information. In fact, There Are Mountains Among the Clouds is a film that is, in the precise sense of the word, minimalist, because it obtains its deep and complex meanings through selective and concise images. Without needing to place a large group of actors in front of the camera, or to design numerous relationships, it tries, solely through the character’s relationship with the world around him, to explore the interior of his mind and, by using metaphorical images, to draw closer to the character’s life. In this regard one must note that the existence of a precise and well-structured screenplay has a significant effect on achieving an excellent result. We are dealing with a film that begins from a simple point—the image of a tree—yet expands and spreads its world so that by the end of the film we are faced with a vast work. When the film ends, although many questions still remain in our minds, what we have seen has in fact settled inside us, and the filmmakers have been able to extend their attitude toward cinema—an attitude that is non-commercial and non-repetitive—to the entire work through characterization. Placing a single character at the center of a feature film (which runs an hour and a half) is a risky undertaking, and the fact that this character is a mysterious and complex person whom we are meant to know through his everyday life doubles the degree of that risk. Nevertheless, the result the filmmakers have achieved is extraordinary. With the help of a principled attitude toward film, a correct attitude toward the function of every shot, and by properly arranging every image, they have arrived at a whole that is expressive and at the same time open to interpretation, a whole that carries the viewer along with it. A great film born from the scenes of everyday life.




Comments